ISSUE NO. 78
Streaming Wars is a weekly opinion column by IGN’s Streaming Editor, Amelia Emberwing. Check out the last entry Did Daredevil: Born Again Just Confirm A Popular Foggy Nelson Fan Theory?
This column entry contains spoilers for the series finale of Mythic Quest.
For those who may have missed it, Mythic Quest, Apple TV+’s beautifully weird show about a game studio and its messed up leadership, has come to an end. Apple TV+ announced that the series was cancelled after Season 4’s, uh, polarizing season finale about two weeks after it aired on March 26, leaving fans of the show somehow more frustrated than they were before. As a result of the cancellation, Apple TV+ has decided to pull the original ending entirely, replacing it with a different finale meant to “tie up loose ends”. But the change isn’t only unsuccessful, it also continues an ugly precedent in streaming.
The original finale was met with mixed response due to a sudden kiss between leads Ian (Rob McElhenney) and Poppy (Charlotte Nicdao). Some found the out of the blue smooch jarring, while others have been waiting the duration of the series for it to finally happen. But the real ire came when fans learned that the shocking moment wouldn’t have any followup after the series’ messy leads finally made out. The original plan had been that Mythic Quest Season 5 would explore the fallout of Ian and Poppy’s kiss.
With future episodes off the table, series producers Megan Ganz, David Hornsby and Rob McElhenney issued a joint statement that ended with “Because endings are hard, with Apple’s blessing we made one final update to our last episode — so we could say goodbye, instead of just game over.”
The updated episode, released on April 18, removes the controversial kiss, swapping it out for a hug and returning Ian and Poppy to their previously existing status quo as they plan to continue work on their game expansion. Is the new ending more palatable? Perhaps. But no one has ever once described a good finale — season or series — as palatable. Big swings might not always work but they are, at least, always interesting. The update does nothing to assuage the disappointment of the cancellation and, worse still, the original ending no longer exists on Apple TV+ at all. This means that the change to the ending doesn’t just mean the series comes to a close with a whisper instead of a bang, it also opens a complicated can of worms when it comes to movie and TV curation and streaming as a whole.
Ultimately, the fact that Poppy and Ian work as characters because of their complicated platonic relationship doesn’t end up being what’s most important here. Hell, even the fact that they made a weaker ending for their series isn’t even the biggest issue. It’s that the original ending was removed entirely that leaves me with so much concern. Alternate endings existed long before streaming, though they’re mostly relegated to film rather than television. But removing access to the original ending entirely is a separate can of worms, one more akin to what Max and Netflix have been up to as they’ve started disappearing films and television series from their respective platforms.
When you exist solely in a digital space, erasure from platforms means that you simply cease to exist. Though there’s a chance that Apple TV+ eventually decides to add the original ending back or offer it later in special features should the series ever get a physical release, its current non-existence continues a frustrating trend in digital media. Having a boring ending is obnoxious in and of itself, but knowing that there was another one that dared to take a risk even when that risk didn’t ultimately pan out? Infuriating!
The change was made to “tie up loose ends,” but all it really accomplishes is watering down the final version for all to see. The creators may have instituted the change themselves, but erasing the original version entirely is a disservice to both them and the fans of the series. Said erasure feels especially egregious given that we were discussing Netflix playing with the Mandela Effect just last week when the streamer released two different versions of the same episode of Black Mirror to mess with fans’ heads. There is absolutely no reason that both versions of the finale can’t exist alongside each other.
It’s a pity that Season 4 of Mythic Quest came and went with little fanfare despite Apple TV+ having enough confidence in the story to give it a spinoff (an anthology series set in the world but without any of the existing characters), but it’s a much bigger bummer that we’re seeing the trend of art disappearance continue, whether that art is good, bad, messy or absurd notwithstanding.
